Boo

What do you think of the idea of justice?

06.02.2023

297

812

Questions Community

The questions community, chat, and discussion.

iň gowusy

täze

2ý

ENFJ

Hamal

I think most people can't agree on a definition for it

112

2ý

INTP

Şir

I leave it to Batman

2ý

INFP

Ekizler

Its a necessity. But its also dangerous when the power over it is in the wrong hands. Everyone has their own opinion of what it entails and some take it too far.

2ý

INTP

Suwboýun

I think people have a very warped concept of justice that is more revenge and less justice. Instead of punishing someone but trying to reform them, people would rather completely destroy the person without ever considering reform.

2ý

ENFJ

Rak

"If it were not for injustice, man would not know justice." It’s a quote . I think it’s needed and must be practiced

2ý

INTJ

I suppose it depends on what kind of justice you are referring to

2ý

INTP

Suwboýun

The human version is flawed. It does not align with the world around it. It does not take inspiration from nature.

2ý

INFJ

Başak

The USA government deliberately complicates it to the point where justice is determined by who has the most money.

2ý

ENFJ

Hamal

Justice has to have a judge, one that follows an individuals idea of what is just. If you live in a society, it's important to know what that society considers unjust. Same as in a relationship.

2ý

INFP

Rak

Well, justice is not fair, it strives for it, but since it's merely perceptual and relies on how we value things with no intrinsic value you can't ever make it fair. We do need Justice, but it's naive to think we could reach a universal understanding of what is just.

2ý

INFJ

Hamal

There's no such thing.

2ý

INFP

Rak

It really depends on what you believe is "justice". It also depends on if you believe in a more punitive approach to it or a more reformatory approach.

2ý

ISFP

Öküz

У каждого своя справедливость. А как таковой справедливости на земле среди людей я не встречала, особенно у власть имущих.

2ý

ENFP

Balyk

Its questions like these that baffle me. Even more crazy that I havent seen anyone react to how preposterous this question is. The sad thing is, I should be use to this by now since Im seeing this a lot lately... apparently its normal these days to call everything an "Idea"... like is everyone postmodernistic by default? I am not living in the times I am suppose to be living in i guess.. but, honestly I wouldnt care so much if people werent so seemingly literal and or militantly unidefinitive. Literalism and semantic fluidity are NOT supposed to mix. Excuse my seemingly immediate lapse of hipocrasy for a second but I must say that, quite literally, They are contradictions by definition. To the poster, first of all, I am aware that perhaps your intentions were honestly harmless and perhaps the question was in some sense constructed out of a genuinely curious impulse, (which imo should never be a valid reason so I hope you had some other reasons regardless of them being cynical in nature), and please dont take this wrong way, I just tend to come off verbose and strong which only amplifies my highly opinionated personality... but I am not claiming to be "right" per se, I am just hoping to meet somewhere in the middle with you... and so first I must ask you, do you see anything 'careless'(i dont want to use the word, 'wrong' here because thats not anywhere near what I want to entail) about that specific question your asking people? If thats kind of a arespondable question for me to ask you and youd rather indulge me on one other instead then just consider this,"What makes you think that 'justice', the word, can be appropriately refered to as an 'idea', the epiphenomena. What do you think an 'idea', the concept, is? Once you thought about that for a second, do you still think that 'justice', the word can be refered to as an 'idea' the, whatever opinion of idea you just conceived of, and be (excuse the highly uncanny irony here) definitively justified? **also to anyone who reads this and thinks that 'justice', the principle, is absolutley subjective, you are wrong. If you think that 'justice' the principle, or 'justice' the cardinal virtue/and value cannot be objective, well, you can't be more wrong about the word 'justice' as how it pertains to actual life and reality. Perhaps it may just be naivety and therefore because it wasnt ever really thought about till now, it was merely apercetive presupposition that just needed angles, thats just learning and there is nothing wrong with thay, but if you are an adult, and have served jury duty or have commited a crime and therefore have been on the docket and have gone to court, and still claim that 'justice' is subjective and or cannot be objective, thats not naivety, thats just willful ignorance.( üýtgedildi )

2ý

ESTP

Şir

Justice cant exist without a clear sense of right and wrong. It is a concept of moral rightness based on either ethics, rationality, law, natural law, religion, equity & fairness.

2ý

ENFP

Hamal

Justice is not for me to decide, and the consequence is not for me to dish out. Justice is a wonderful "concept" but it is not one for us to control, or make.

2ý

ENFJ

Oğlak

I dream that one day justice will have a definition more akin to "everyone holding each other up" rather than "a few that push people down."

2ý

INFJ

Owaç

Justice is objective. People twist it around to suite their own needs mostly because people are hypocritical. Starts as a child. Don't drink, smoke, or cuss because it's bad but parents say it while holding a beer. Do as I say not as I do. People look onto others and pass judgement based on the actions of the criminal but would ask for mercy for themselves if it were relative to them.

2ý

ISFP

Terezi

Life is unfair, at all time. It seems

2ý

ISFJ

Hamal

Everyone has their own definition. And not one will ever match up.

2ý

ENTJ

Balyk

What goes around comes around

2ý

ENFP

Balyk

Pienso que ante las injusticias, lo justo llega tarde o temprano de la manera que sea. Recibimos lo que merecemos y lo que damos

2ý

INTJ

Başak

The philosophy of justice varies based on personal beliefs, but some consider Rawls' Social Contract Theory or Virtue Ethics as deeper approaches. Rawls considers both individual and collective interests in justice, while Virtue Ethics emphasizes character and motivations. The "deepest" approach depends on individual cultural, religious, and political beliefs.

2ý

INTJ

Rak

It's subjective. Personally I think people mistake revenge for justice.

2ý

INTJ

Ekizler

What is just is not always right and what is right is not always just.

2ý

INTP

Terezi

As long as the criminally rich rule this world, there can be no true overarching justice. They will always get out of their horrible deeds with a slap on the wrist, while innocent lives continue to suffer at their hand.

2ý

INFP

Öküz

It depends

2ý

INFP

Terezi

Justice is feeling good that something bad happened to bad person, or the punitive cost incurred by doing wrong. Just a idea ✌️

2ý

INFP

Rak

'Justice' has the same perceptual issues as 'power' both meaning have detonation but the perception of the individual is what differs.

2ý

ENTJ

I think justice is our best effort to curb our inherently violent nature born from a time when we were attacking each other in tribes with bows and arrows. It is something that we must strive to achieve, even if in our current society it is skewed in one groups favor (looking at the rich and powerful) we will never gain a better future if we don't do our best to right the wrongs of our neighbours and of ourselves.

2ý

ESTP

Ekizler

Well let me ask you this. How is the Justice in your country?

2ý

ESFP

Öküz

Hmm

2ý

INFP

Şir

I study criminology and i have to say its relative, and mostly defined by the powerful groups in society

2ý

ISFP

Hamal

Justice is subjective but also objective. Its definition will differ from person to person, but everyone tends to agree we all need it.

2ý

INFP

Owaç

Hi

2ý

INTP

Hamal

Justice, like written history, is in the hands of those with power. It is what they want it to be. For some it's beheading for not believing, others it's imprisoning one race whole letting another of for the same crime. For many it's revenge or payback. Truth, equity and transparency seem to be missing in most places today

Täze Adamlar Bilen Tanyş

50 000 000+ DOWNLOADS

If you had to choose to practice only one sport for the rest of your life, which would it be and why?

05.02.2023

444

1538

What messages are you refusing to hear ?

04.02.2023

305

923

What key event/object will make you know that you've achieved all you want in life?

03.02.2023

452

947

What do you think of the idea of justice?

Questions Community

I think most people can't agree on a definition for it

I leave it to Batman

Its a necessity. But its also dangerous when the power over it is in the wrong hands. Everyone has their own opinion of what it entails and some take it too far.

I think people have a very warped concept of justice that is more revenge and less justice. Instead of punishing someone but trying to reform them, people would rather completely destroy the person without ever considering reform.

"If it were not for injustice, man would not know justice." It’s a quote . I think it’s needed and must be practiced

I suppose it depends on what kind of justice you are referring to

The human version is flawed. It does not align with the world around it. It does not take inspiration from nature.

The USA government deliberately complicates it to the point where justice is determined by who has the most money.

Justice has to have a judge, one that follows an individuals idea of what is just. If you live in a society, it's important to know what that society considers unjust. Same as in a relationship.

Well, justice is not fair, it strives for it, but since it's merely perceptual and relies on how we value things with no intrinsic value you can't ever make it fair. We do need Justice, but it's naive to think we could reach a universal understanding of what is just.

There's no such thing.

It really depends on what you believe is "justice". It also depends on if you believe in a more punitive approach to it or a more reformatory approach.

У каждого своя справедливость. А как таковой справедливости на земле среди людей я не встречала, особенно у власть имущих.

Justice cant exist without a clear sense of right and wrong. It is a concept of moral rightness based on either ethics, rationality, law, natural law, religion, equity & fairness.

Justice is not for me to decide, and the consequence is not for me to dish out. Justice is a wonderful "concept" but it is not one for us to control, or make.

I dream that one day justice will have a definition more akin to "everyone holding each other up" rather than "a few that push people down."

Life is unfair, at all time. It seems

Everyone has their own definition. And not one will ever match up.

What goes around comes around

Pienso que ante las injusticias, lo justo llega tarde o temprano de la manera que sea. Recibimos lo que merecemos y lo que damos

It's subjective. Personally I think people mistake revenge for justice.

What is just is not always right and what is right is not always just.

As long as the criminally rich rule this world, there can be no true overarching justice. They will always get out of their horrible deeds with a slap on the wrist, while innocent lives continue to suffer at their hand.

It depends

Justice is feeling good that something bad happened to bad person, or the punitive cost incurred by doing wrong. Just a idea ✌️

'Justice' has the same perceptual issues as 'power' both meaning have detonation but the perception of the individual is what differs.

Well let me ask you this. How is the Justice in your country?

Hmm

I study criminology and i have to say its relative, and mostly defined by the powerful groups in society

Justice is subjective but also objective. Its definition will differ from person to person, but everyone tends to agree we all need it.

Hi

Related Posts

If you had to choose to practice only one sport for the rest of your life, which would it be and why?

What messages are you refusing to hear ?

What key event/object will make you know that you've achieved all you want in life?