Brad
Brad

2y

INTP

Cancer

Do you believe you have free will? (edited)

16

96

Comment

Psychology Community

The psychology community, chat, and discussion.

JOIN NOW

2.2M SOULS

best
new
Alex

Alex

2y

ENTJ

Libra

It depends on definition of free will. I like deterministic theories, but even if we theoretically can predict everything, this doesn't mean we aren't capable to make decisions. Determinism is a believe in causes, so if we mean a freedom from causes, then of course we haven't free will. But, if the definition is ability to make our own decisions, then we have free will. The chain of cause and effect is partially consist of you, your brain and your body. The processes that are produced by your own body (like hormonal changes) is part of you, so these are your decisions. And I really don't like things like "we are slaves of our brain, it's controlling me", because you are your brain. So yeah, we have power of choice

2

11

Reply

Christopher

Christopher

2y

INFP

Leo

7
6

No we don't have free will because for me thoughts don't come from our brain they are external,our brain just decides how to decipher those thoughts and use them appropriately

0

1

Reply

Michael

Michael

2y

INTP

Virgo

4
5

Yes. However I also think reality / physics is basically deterministic. Legit not sure how to reconcile the two...

1

1

Reply

Lili (pseudonym)

Lili (pseudonym)

2y

INTP

4
5

I believe that ultimately it doesn't matter whether it's free will or deterministic. As we all want to live a good and peaceful society and punish these that commit crimes against it, even if the crimes weren't a product of 'free will'. The alternative to me would be complete anarchy, as everyone would just do whatever since they're not responsible for their actions

0

1

Reply

Laurie

Laurie

2y

INTJ

Capricorn

I would say yes but... A very 'limited' type of freedom bounds to each individual level of self-awareness and the simple fact that we are living beings limited by our body's needs and reactions. So... The question could be: if there is limitations, is it really freedom? ๐Ÿค” (edited)

0

7

Reply

Sinko

Sinko

2y

ENTP

Gemini

I'm a pretty hard determinist, so no.

0

0

Reply

Christopher

Christopher

2y

INFP

Leo

7
6

Ok Brian ๐Ÿ˜Œ

0

0

Reply

Brad

Brad

Author

2y

INTP

Cancer

Just changed the question lol Reading a book that's got me thinking so just wanted some more perspectives

0

0

Reply

Nathan

Nathan

2y

INTJ

Aries

Free will is the illusion of choice.

0

0

Reply

Ryan

Ryan

2y

INTP

Cancer

9
8

No

0

0

Reply

Meet New People

50,000,000+

DOWNLOADS

JOIN NOW

Related Posts

#psychology

Jade
Jade

12h

INFP

Leo

2
3

I cant comprehend

I can't handle breakups well I can't handle breakups well I can't handle breakups well I can't handle breakups well I can't handle breakups well I can't handle breakups well I can't handle breakups well I can't handle breakups well I can't handle breakups well I can't handle breakups well I can't... read more

5

16

#psychology

Dolly
Dolly

9h

INFP

Gemini

4
5

โค๏ธโค๏ธโค๏ธโค๏ธโค๏ธโค๏ธ

โค๏ธโค๏ธโค๏ธโค๏ธโค๏ธโค๏ธ

10

3

#psychology

Karim
Karim

22h

ISTJ

Libra

1
2

โ—‹

โ—‹

5

2

#psychology

`โ€ข.,ยธยธ,.โ€ขยดยฏ โ„“โ“Žฮท ยฏ`โ€ข.,ยธยธ,.โ€ขยด
`โ€ข.,ยธยธ,.โ€ขยดยฏ โ„“โ“Žฮท ยฏ`โ€ข.,ยธยธ,.โ€ขยด

21h

ISFJ

Leo

6
7

7 Types of Rest ๐Ÿ“Œ๐Ÿ’Ÿ

7 Types of Rest ๐Ÿ“Œ๐Ÿ’Ÿ

4

1

#psychology

Emelyne
Emelyne

2y

INFP

Libra

4
5

Life purpose

Do you know what your life purpose is? If so, how did you discover it?

5

6

#psychology

Stephen
Stephen

1d

ESTJ

Pisces

8
7

Heh

Heh

4

5

#psychology

Ron
Ron

9h

INTP

Scorpio

8
7

Live fast die young....be wild have fun

Live fast die young....be wild have fun

1

2

#psychology

Jatin Thakur
Jatin Thakur

2y

INFP

Taurus

8
9

Liked vs Loved your comment

I've been noticing how this app allows you to love posts, instead of liking. It's a subtle differences but I feel it brings more deeper connection when we do love. Because for our subconscious minds, we are loving the post and hence the person as well. Do you think this to be the case? Or it... read more

Liked vs Loved your comment

2

0

#psychology

Emircan
Emircan

2h

ENFJ

Scorpio

6
7

.

Let me to celebrate my defeat.

3

0

#psychology

Oliver
Oliver

2y

ENTP

Aquarius

6
7

The big 5 works better than Myers-Briggs.

Here's a rough self-portrait: Openness - very high Conscientiousness - average Extroversion - high Agreeableness - fairly low Neuroticism - low

1

2

#psychology

Ajay kumar
Ajay kumar

8h

INTJ

Scorpio

Who wrote this ???

Who wrote this ???

2

1

#psychology

Rio
Rio

12h

ISTJ

Taurus

8
7

Food for thought ๐Ÿง ๐Ÿ’ญ

Food for thought ๐Ÿง ๐Ÿ’ญ
Food for thought ๐Ÿง ๐Ÿ’ญ
1/2

2

0

#psychology

Siva
Siva

13h

ENTJ

Gemini

What did you observe in your city recent times?

Your adulthood has now arrived. You could see and observe a lot of things while you work, travel, and study in different cities. What alterations do you see in the social and official life of your cities? [Please provide the country, city, and changes.]

1

1

#psychology

Jade
Jade

1d

INFP

Leo

2
3

I dont feel real

I feel like im watching myself everything is fake

13

13

#psychology

Dev
Dev

21h

ISTP

Taurus

8
7

That's me!

That's me!

4

0

#psychology

Karim
Karim

23h

ISTJ

Libra

1
2

~

~

2

1

#psychology

Y***
Y***

6h

INTJ

8
9

Women

I don't understand women are judged on their beauty, and why can't repeat clothes or follow hard beauty routines, for a real person, personality matters more so build it.

1

0

#psychology

Maane
Maane

20h

ISTJ

Pisces

9
1

Soul treatment โค๏ธ

Hello buddies. Have a well protected soul no matter what. Don't allow anger and hatred to it. Enjoy your weekend with self love and care.

Soul treatment โค๏ธ

2

2

#psychology

Vulpes
Vulpes

5h

INFP

Leo

6
5

I'm back and diagnosed, friends! Now is for sure, I'm crazy./Estou de volta e com laudo, amigos! Agora, com certeza, sou doido. ๐ŸฆŠ (edited)

3

3

#psychology

๐Ÿ•Š๏ธ๐Ÿ™๐Ÿผ๐Ÿ•Š๏ธElissaTrue
๐Ÿ•Š๏ธ๐Ÿ™๐Ÿผ๐Ÿ•Š๏ธElissaTrue

1d

INFJ

Aquarius

8
7

๐Ÿ•Š๏ธWhat a lovely ๐Ÿ’ก So yes Moderation is necessary ๐ŸŽถ๐Ÿ™๐Ÿป

6

12

#psychology

Alderson
Alderson

14h

INTP

Leo

5
4

Company ๐Ÿ’™

Having someone in life makes it worth living and the future seem less scary.

Company ๐Ÿ’™

5

1

#psychology

Vishnu
Vishnu

6h

ENFJ

Capricorn

If someone is emotionally available for us. That will solve most of our problems.

0

2

#psychology

Nick
Nick

20h

ISTJ

Scorpio

9
1

Feelings

What you feel is a illusion, so stop following what you feel and start believing in yourself..you got this Just breathe

3

6

#psychology

Tyler
Tyler

1d

INFP

Virgo

Psychology interest

Iโ€™m looking into getting my Masters in Counseling, and wanted to ask everyone- What Sparked your interest in Paychology?

3

1

#psychology

Joe
Joe

1d

INTP

Leo

8
7

Canโ€™t do complaining today.

Did it yesterday and it didnโ€™t help.

4

0

#psychology

Nessy
Nessy

5d

ENTJ

Virgo

Everybody is seeking deep connection while keeping their heart locked ๐Ÿ”’ that's when healing is needed

43

11

#psychology

Victoria
Victoria

4d

ISFP

Leo

They call me crazy bc they can't call me ugly

They call me crazy bc they can't call me ugly

30

7

#psychology

Caedus
Caedus

23d

INTP

4
5

My mood for the week honestly:

My mood for the week honestly:

51

9

#psychology

Su
Su

6d

ESFP

Capricorn

Good morning, what do you say first when you wake up?

9

23

#psychology

Ramin
Ramin

1d

ENTJ

Virgo

๐Ÿ‘Œ

5

0

#psychology

Jake
Jake

13d

INTJ

Scorpio

Would you rather be with someone who always has your back, no questions askedโ€”or someone who pushes you to think differently, even if it means calling you out sometimes? Why?

9

9

#psychology

Ann
Ann

15d

INFJ

Aquarius

It cost zero $$ to be KIND

It cost zero $$ to be KIND

33

9

#psychology

Neila
Neila

5d

INTP

Libra

8
7

Reminds me someone I used to know ๐Ÿฆ– ๐Ÿ‘‰๐Ÿป๐Ÿ‘ˆ๐Ÿป

And not all dinosaur experience BPD this way. There are 9 criteria and different dinosaur can have various combinations of those criteria and experience the same criteria in very different ways. Also, don't worry dinosaur! BPD can go into remission, meaning dinosaur feels better and symptoms become... read more

15

4

#psychology

Sarah
Sarah

4d

INTJ

Virgo

8
7

When books arts history and fashion is your soul calling ๐Ÿ’–โœจ Can you guess what book am holding???? (edited)

When books arts history and fashion is your soul calling ๐Ÿ’–โœจ
Can you guess what book am holding????
When books arts history and fashion is your soul calling ๐Ÿ’–โœจ
Can you guess what book am holding????
1/2

16

30

#psychology

Geanny
Geanny

3d

INTP

Leo

The nonchalant

Mostly, those people who act nonchalant are the most caring and loving person in the inside ๐Ÿ’– โœจ

13

6

#psychology

Noรฉrah
Noรฉrah

9d

INFJ

Virgo

2
1

Who you are when nobody is watching ?

20

65

#psychology

Sarah
Sarah

6d

INTJ

Virgo

8
7

Bye Bye ๐Ÿ”ฅ๐Ÿ˜œ

Bye Bye ๐Ÿ”ฅ๐Ÿ˜œ

13

6

#psychology

Mike
Mike

3d

ISTJ

Leo

What get you pissed off real quick?

4

29

#psychology

Jeanette
Jeanette

4d

INFP

Pisces

4
5

What mental illnesses do you have?

6

10

#psychology

Jeanette
Jeanette

17d

INFP

Pisces

4
5

What are you doing to work on your toxic traits?

11

32