We use cookies on our website for a number of purposes, including analytics, performance, and advertising. Learn more.
OK!
Boo
SIGN IN
Universes
Posted Monday, September 12, 2022
2y
INFP
Gemini
Getting lost in the determinist sauce
I have been thinking about the concept of free will in relation to our understanding of time. Because time for humans is linear we base our understanding of freedom and choice off of it. Your actions influence the world around you and have consequences. Your decision might have been influenced by outside forces, however, you still made the choice and must live with it. On the other hand, what if we did live in a determinist universe? Would we still be able to hold people accountable for their actions if they never truly had a choice? Beyond that, considering that (and I am using broad strokes here) we all base our morality on the fact that we do have freedom to choose. What would we use as the basis for a "good person", or is trying to define such a thing an exercise in futility. Since in this hypothetical, all choices where predetermined, would all action suddenly lose value? Would the moral weight be lifted knowing that the actions you took where the only you ever could? How would we even define ourselves without choice? TLDR: my sleeping meds are kicking in and making me extra existential tonight (: Edit: I just wanted to clarify where how I sorta feel about a lot of this since 3am was a not really focused on that. I do believe that our actions do have value, by the very nature of how our world works. Our actions ripple out in thousands of different ways, effecting people in ways we could never even think of. Beyond that, the 4th dimension is that of time. We are strangle little noodles moving through the universe, interlacing and changing. Even if everything has a set point, isn't there still value in following a set path? In watching a movie despite knowing the ending? Despite that I am still very tired so who knows TTLDR: I am even more tired than yesterday but have no interest in keeping my half baked ideas to myself (edited)
6
8
Comment
Philosophy Community
The philosophy community, chat, and discussion.
JOIN NOW
936K SOULS
Kelly
2y
ENFP
I believe we're in a determinist universe because I haven't seen any evidence otherwise. But we can't prove or disprove that without being able to see the future, so how much does determinism matter to present actions? I don't think it does. Therefore we still need to hold people accountable. There's no way to predict the future even if it's completely set in stone. The only way we know to influence people's actions is via incentives, and holding people accountable is an effective way to incentivize good behavior. When it comes to judging the moral weight held by others, personally I feel that's a metaphysical concept that's hard to define. I think that each of us needs to take responsibility for taking moral actions, and we need to have a society/culture that instills that personal responsibility in every person. The idea of morals and personal accountability are helpful for making decisions in the present and the future. But when it comes to looking at the past, I do think there's comfort in knowing it couldn't have been any other way. And I think it helps reduce feelings of anger to realize someone was likely destined from the beginning of time to act that way.
1
0
Reply
rhys
2y
ENTP
Virgo
- we may not be accountable for our actions, but that isn't going to stop people from holding others accountable for their actions, regardless. - i don't think there should be a basis for a good person, when no one can agree on what exactly a good person is; it makes the entire concept meaningless. - no one's actions are valuable, period. everybody dies, and everything goes extinct. all of our choices will ultimately be forgotten when the last human takes their last breath. you can only imagine your own meaning in the actions you take, it can only matter to you as long as you live. whether or not your actions are influenced or made by freedom of choice should not affect their value. the influence or freedom of choice in and of themselves make the action valuable to you either way.
1
0
Reply
Kurson
2y
INFJ
Aries
The simple answer/response to this post is that the concept of morality by in large is flawed when observed in nature. No one particularly* cares about a "good" person, but will fight tooth and nail to punish a "bad" one. This dichotomy is important to recognize because it shows that there is no incentive to be a good person at all except perhaps fear of punishment (prison/death/hell(?) ). Since fear, and in general, negative-reinforcement is the biggest reason to be "good", one can conclude that morality, regardless of free-will, really matters to society as a whole. On the other hand, to the individual, observing good people doing good things (in person or otherwise) makes us feel good and that dopaminergic response is a subconscious positive-reinforcement mechanism that classically-conditions us to like good people because they make us feel good and also this motivates us to also be good people. Although I only mentioned 2 factors that goes into the sociology (fear) and psychology (intrinsic value) of morality, my point is that society doesn't nearly value morality as much as the individual does. As a result, and finally the response you've been waiting for, even in a deterministic universe I would argue that if what I said was a scientific law then society would deterministically punish the bad and the individual will feel good about the good regardless of free-will and choice. This makes sense to me, because even in a deterministic universe, the universe itself still operates within the laws of physics and thus, imo, society and the individual will also operate within the confines of its own laws. Now the other big question is: How "real" is the concept of free-will and autonomy? Hopefully I didn't completely miss your intentions and/or didn't quite meet your expectations in terms of getting a valuable/relevant response 😇
0
1
Reply
Paul
2y
INTJ
Aries
see compatibilism
0
0
Reply
Meet New People
40,000,000+ DOWNLOADS
JOIN NOW
Related Posts
#philosophy
8h
INFJ
Sagittarius
It is not necessary that every person who comes into our lives is meant to stay. Everyone serves a purpose. Only the ones made for us are meant to stay.
13
3
#philosophy
5h
INTJ
Virgo
Trump or Kamala ? Honest Answer, Honest People
4
15
#love
8h
INTJ
✌️
To the person who is lost, depressed and wondering if life is worth living, I wish that happiness and love finds you wherever you are and gives you the strength to get up off your knees and feel free. Sunshine and rainbows forever #mentalawareness #depression #philosophy
9
3
#philosophy
17h
ENTJ
Taurus
Support system
As someone who came from an unsupportive family life with limited contact to most relatives I can tell you that lacking moral support is detrimental to children and adults. Do you have a good support system? Are they mostly friends or actual bio family? Mental health really need to be taken more... read more
All family
Some friends, some family
Created my own family
27 votes
9
6
#philosophy
2y
INTJ
Virgo
Who else believes some relationships are very disappointing?
Sometimes I'm just at awe with how disappointing some of the various everyday people we interact with are. What are some things you wish you saw a lot more of in people:
2
2
#philosophy
19h
INTP
Virgo
Arachnophobia bested
I over came my Arachnophobia today, and I just wanted to share it, it's a big deal for me 😆 (edited)
7
5
#philosophy
6h
INTJ
Virgo
Do you prefer the city or the countryside?
2
10
#philosophy
2y
INFP
Capricorn
I don't fake a image
I'm just being real with myself and y'all hate it or love it take me as I am. I don't gotta pose being nice and genuine my existence an nature is already that sl what's there to fake? Y'all got me hurt thinking I'm pretending for women's attention I ain't y'all.
7
4
#philosophy
19h
ESTP
Aries
Forget me not..
I forgot my surname , can i have yours ??
6
2
#philosophy
4h
INFP
Taurus
Ideas
Hey yall drop your biggest philosophy/deep questions about life and the universe u got, I wanna have a mid life crisis :)!
5
4
#philosophy
15h
ISFJ
Gemini
What is the purpose of life according to you??
3
7
#philosophy
4h
INTJ
Virgo
Do you believe in fate, or do we create our own destiny?
3
4
#philosophy
22h
INFJ
Capricorn
😇
When we let of our thoughts and inner voices, we first notice the isness of anything a around us without any distortion.
6
2
#philosophy
21h
ENFJ
Aquarius
The Universe is vast, far larger than most can begin to comprehend. And we are small, tiny grains of sand on an impossibly huge beach. Yet each of us has a Universe within us. If you want to understand everything, get to know the Universe within
5
1
#philosophy
7h
ENTP
Gemini
How to learn to be okay not being in a relationship.
Step 1 is to realize your self worth is in your control. Realizing that having or not having someone doesn't change your value as a person. You're not competing with anyone on being worthy of love so who would you degrade yourself against for not having a partner? What standard are you holding... read more
3
5
#philosophy
19h
INFJ
Libra
Never judge a book by its cover
3
2
#philosophy
21h
ENFP
Capricorn
Hegel & Persia
Hegel considered the ancient Persians to be the first historic people: “In Persia first arises that light which shines itself and illuminates what is around... The principle of development begins with the history of Persia; this constitutes therefore the beginning of history” (Hegel, 1857, p.... read more
5
0
#philosophy
14h
ISFP
Capricorn
We and the universe are one in the same
I believe that you'll never truly be able to fulfill 'love' to your greatest capacity until you learn to understand that you, everyone and everything around you— are infact different versions of you experience 'yourself'— the cosmos and all its duality, what better way to entertain a god, except... read more
3
1
#philosophy
17h
ISTJ
Taurus
Money
If you chase after money you will never gonna make enough of it, if you do the work what are you good at, that will bring you money .
3
0
#philosophy
16h
INTP
Taurus
🙏🏻 grateful for this journey
2
1
#philosophy
10h
ISFP
Aries
Build Beyond the Surface"
A real connection isn’t found; it’s built. 💪 Every conversation is a brick, every laugh a foundation. Aim for depth, not just attraction. 💥
3
0
#philosophy
11h
ISTP
Aries
The philosopher legacy
Once upon a time, in the bustling city of ancient Athens, a young philosopher named Socrates walked the streets, engaging in conversations that would shape the course of Western thought. Socrates was known for his unique method of questioning, which encouraged people to think critically about their... read more
3
0
#philosophy
19h
ISFP
Sagittarius
If any loves you truly that is you .
2
1
#philosophy
13h
INFP
Gemini
Wealthy
3
0
#philosophy
7h
INTJ
Aquarius
Nothing defines humans better than their willingness to do irrational things in the pursuit of phenomenally unlikely payoffs. This is the principle behind lotteries, dating, and religion.
1
1
#philosophy
13h
INFP
Gemini
Boss lady
2
0
#philosophy
19h
INTJ
Taurus
Feels like a trash
Instead of seeing old stuff as dirty, useless trash we throw away, we need to think of it as stuff you use for a while and then pass on to somebody else in the positive way. So we need not just to recycle and compost, but to reuse and repurpose. Old and used doesn’t have to mean dirty trash.... read more
1
0
#philosophy
15h
ENTJ
Taurus
I am gonna close account and bounce
sorry peepe. Was fun first few day. Are lots laugh. And not just spending while time explain my self and getting more ppl upset. Wasn't intentione. have a good niv 11th.remember your poppies please. And aight. My apologies. I thought this was yoing ok. And all did was put a targete on me. Welr.... read more
0
2
#philosophy
7h
ENTP
Taurus
The life vitamins
How do you fell before?
1
0
#philosophy
11h
INTP
Aries
don't come back don't give in to nostalgija forget us all
who would give these advice to their young ones? any opitions
1
0
#philosophy
15h
INTJ
Libra
The Greatest Power is to be without.
1
0
#philosophy
5h
INFP
Pisces
Nuh nuh
1
0
#philosophy
7h
ENFJ
Aquarius
Happiness
Have a beautiful day!
1
0
#philosophy
1d
INTP
Aries
😌
2
0
#philosophy
1d
INTP
Aries
😌
1
0
#philosophy
2h
ENTP
Taurus
Otha
Otha
0
0
#philosophy
1d
ENFJ
Sagittarius
Time flies
Artist: @Raposilba Despite our dark eyes, scars, messy hair and traumas, we're still Us... We're still standing, older and wiser, and ever so slightly messy.
1
0
#philosophy
12h
ISFJ
Leo
I Don't Trust Words
0
0
#philosophy
1d
ENTJ
Leo
#Mountains
If you find god in a rock , so I worship a mountain
0
1
#philosophy
1d
INTJ
Capricorn
Playing with near words in Persian فارسی
درست است که #آستانه نام شهر ای ست در قزاقستان ؛اما برای ما واژه ای ست قبل از تحمل؛ قبل شکستن. اولی را درکتاب جغرافیا دیدم و دومی را ؛ در #جبر جغرافیا ! iri (edited)
0
3
#philosophy
8d
INFP
Who agrees? 🖤
#life #people #universe #soul #relationships #showerthoughts #boo
111
15